Skip to the good stuff

 

toolboxPro/Con Tables

go through pagepage contents

What

How

Go On


-------

navigate in the page--What Is It Good For?

 

As this tool quickly shows the bottom line, it works especially well for briefings to decisionmakers or publics. If you have a go/no go decision, use a pro/con table to briefly demonstrate your rationale. Many of the analyses and discussions of proposed alternatives or options dance around a central question: will the pros outweigh the cons? The simplicity of the table is deceptive; it is one of the best ways to think through a difficult issue. A pro/con table can show both sides quickly so you can better see the entire picture. This is also a quick way to evaluate and select alternatives.

 


-------

navigate in the page--How Do I Use It?

 

Start by brainstorming by using this table or use the results from other analyses and techniques. Write down a pro or con and its analogous con or pro. For example, if lining a canal will reduce seepage (pro) then it may also reduce groundwater recharge from seepage (con).

For example, here is a simple pro/con table for recharging treated water:

 

Pro/Con table 1

Pro

Con

Provide peaking water supplies

Expensive

Easy maintenance

Public may perceive health risk

To compare the pros and cons of more than one option, you can create a more complex table:

 

Pro/Con table 2

Water recharge

Water conservation

Pro

Con

Pro

Con

Provide peaking
water supplies

Expensive
source of water

Inexpensive

Continuous education needed

Easy maintenance

May pose perceived health risk

Perceived to be safer water source

Doesn't provide
stable source of water

For decisions involving more than two choices, you can create a pro/con table with weights. MATS is a very effective way to do this in more detail.

     
  1. List each factor that provides evidence for or against various alternatives.

     

  2. Assign weights to each factor to reflect their relative importance.

     

  3. Make a numerical rating of the extent to which the evidence about each factor favors (or argues against) each alternative.

     

  4. Multiply the score each item gets on each factor by the weight assigned to that factor, then add up all the results to get an overall score for each alternative.

 


-------

navigate in the page--Go On

GeneralToolbox

PreviousTool Selection Worksheet

NextTool List

 

 

 


Note: These files were developed and were originally hosted at the Bureau of Reclamation, United States Department of the Interior.
Eastgate is hosting this as an archive. Contact Deena Larsen for further information.